Silent film star Buster Keaton earned the nickname “The Great Stone Face” because of his superhuman ability to maintain composure while disaster reigned around him; the quadrant of presidential faces on Mount Rushmore had more animation. AP’s 1966 obituary of Keaton stated, “Unlike Mr. Chaplin, he was never sentimental and he never resorted to maudlin pathos. He turned a granite face to the wildly comic and nightmarish cries that befell him—and he always prevailed over impending doom.”
In his 1928 silent film The Cameraman, Keaton plays the title role—an aspiring cameraman at MGM with a crush on the secretary to the executive in charge of newsreels.
An extended scene features Keaton miming a baseball game at Yankee Stadium after learning that the Yankees are in St. Louis on a road trip. In one part, Keaton imitates a batter getting knocked down, shouting at the pitcher, and hitting an inside-the-park home run capped by a headfirst slide into home plate. Keaton’s sprint around the bases provided the opportunity to showcase the grandeur of Yankee Stadium, which is arguably more imposing without a game; its emptiness reinforces its size. Keaton’s baseball fandom, legendary in the filmmaking community, undoubtedly inspired the Yankee Stadium scene.
In a striking bit of coincidence, The Cameraman premiered during the Yankees’ Midwestern road trip of September 15-30, which began with the Bronx Bombers taking on the St. Louis Browns, followed by the Chicago White Sox, the Cleveland Indians, and the Detroit Tigers.
Keaton, a comedy legend, followed an exacting blueprint to obtain laughs. Though comedy is a craft and not a science, it comes pretty close to the latter. In the September 16, 1928 edition of the New York Herald Tribune, the article “Buster Keaton On the Timing Of the Laugh” explains that The Cameraman is the “feature at the Capitol this week” before launching into Keaton’s detailed explanation of comedy. Of particular importance is the insight regarding the beginning of the story.
“For instance, in the opening scenes of ‘The Cameraman’ I’m picked up alone in front of the New York City Hall,” states Keaton. “I get a customer for a tintype picture, and, just as I’m about to snap the camera—this is carefully indicated by timed pauses—in rushes a crowd and upsets the works. This, then, is topped by confetti and the disclosure that a famous character is coming along. In rush the newsreel cameramen and I get tangled up in their camera tripods. Between each development we had to figure just where a laugh might come in and how long a pause was necessary to take care of this.”
The Cameraman is a highlight in Keaton’s impressive body of work. A downward trajectory ensued. “After the success of The Cameraman, Keaton begged MGM for his own independent unit, but the studio refused,” wrote Lisle Foote in her 2014 book Buster Keaton’s Crew: The Team Behind His Silent Films. “His films became less and less funny, and even [director Edward] Sedgwick couldn’t stop the slide in quality. The changes in comedies with the coming of sound, Keaton’s personal troubles, and the difficulties of working within a large and bureaucratic studio all contributed to the decline of Keaton’s films.”
A version of this article appeared on www.thesportspost.com on May 5, 2016.
Share this post
Tags: 1928, 2014, AP, Bronx, Bronx Bombers, Browns, Buster Keaton, Edward Sedgwick, Great Stone Face, Lisle Foote, New York, New York City, New York City Hall, New York Herald Tribune, St. Louis, St. Louis Browns, The Cameraman, The Great Stone Face, Yankee Stadium